Michael Kay has some concerns over CBS’s decision to move on from Phil Simms and Boomer Esiason.
On his ESPN Radio show on Tuesday, Kay wondered if the network’s decision to cut ties with the two former quarterbacks in favor of Matt Ryan and J.J. Watt was based on age.
Simms, 68, and Esiason, 63, had both been with the network for over 20 years and were most recently analysts on “The NFL Today” studio show that aired every Sunday before, after and during halftime of games.
“Boomer’s been there 22 years, Phil 26 years,” Kay said in a segment clipped by Awful Announcing.
“I hope CBS buttoned everything up. Because if you’re getting rid of guys just because of their age, you’re going to get yourself in trouble. Can’t fire somebody because of their age.”
Kay noted the network could point to the decision to keep James Brown, 73, as the host.
CBS also held onto former Steelers coach Bill Cowher for the show and he is 66 years old.
The contracts for Simms, Esiason, Brown and Cowher were up after the 2023 season.
“Like people say, they’re always looking for the next person,” Simms told Front Office Sports. “I’ve heard they like young people too. OK … Whatever the bosses want, that’s what they do. And I understand that.”
Nate Burleson is also remaining on the show and is expected to have a more prominent role.
Watt, 35, previously had a part-time role on “The NFL Today,” while the 38-year-old Ryan had impressed execs as a game analyst.
“Do you really believe that Matt Ryan is more relevant than Boomer Esiason and Phil Simms?” Kay asked co-host Don La Greca.
It is the start of a new era at CBS Sports that goes beyond NFL coverage.
Sean McManus stepped down as chairman after 27 years and is being replaced by David Berson, who had been the president of CBS Sports since 2013.
Kay suggested the new look for the show could be Berson trying to put his stamp on it.
“They brought a new guy in who wants to put his own imprint,” Kay said.